The case for a peace studiesfeminism alliance by catia c. This article introduces a concept of cultural violence, and can be seen as a followup of the authors introduction of the concept of structural violence over 20 years ago galtung. It first traces the emergence and development of the analytical concepts of structural and cultural violence in peace studies, demonstrating how these lenses draw central insights from, but also differ from and improve upon, critical theory and reflexive sociology. It refers to a form of violence wherein some social structure or social institution may harm people by preventing them from meeting their basic needs. It covers such concepts as direct, structural and cultural violence. Abstract this paper addresses an important conceptual question surrounding the categorisation of honourbased violence hereafter hbv is hbv a subspecies of domestic violence hereafter dv.
Cultural and structural violence cause direct violence. Anything galtung forum understanding galtungs violence. Civilization theory is an exploration of cultural violence focusing on cosmologies, codes, and programs. Three types of violence even though the discourse has privileged agent driven, direct forms of violence direct or personal violence structural violence cultural violence 11. The role of structural violence peace researchers as well as antiwar activists generally concentrate their efforts on understanding and preventing armed conflicts and the incidence of overt violence. This is related to the conflict worker through violence practice in diagnosis, prognosis and early warning. In moving from problem to solution, it has four key steps 1 uncovering as much basic knowledge as. Foucault and galtung on structural violence irenees. Typologies of violence and peace religious literacy project.
Pioneer of peace research johan galtung, dietrich fischer auth. If you have access to a journal via a society or association membership, please browse to your society journal, select an article to view, and follow the instructions in this box. This paper is a theoretical discussion of the definitions and dimensions of the terms peace and violence in the field of peace research. The role of structural violence linnbenton community. Cultural violence cultural violence authors johan galtung. Philip leech, globalization cafe transcend media service. Direct violence, physical andor verbal, is visible as behaviour in the triangle. If peace is used to largely mean the absence of violence, then it is crucial to understand the many facets of violence. Books by johan galtung author of peace by peaceful means. Galtungs structural violence and the sierra leone civil war c. Violence lowers the real level of needs satisfaction below what is potentially possible.
While direct, physical violence gets much more attention, the injustice that is built into almost all social systems can. Structural violence is a term commonly ascribed to johan galtung, which he introduced in the. Structural violence this question of structure and constrained agency is particularly crucial for structural violence theorists. Understanding the role of culture in domestic violence. For johan galtung, the us is simultaneously a republic and an empire, a distinction he believes is highly relevant. According to giorgio gallo and arturo marzano the clear. Roughly, structural violence is violence that results in harm but is not caused by a clearly identifiable actor, and positive peace is the absence of structural violence.
Finally, the threads of these four approaches are drawn together with a focus on peace. Structural violence often requires police states to suppress resentments and social unrest. Cultural violence johan galtung journal of peace research, vol. According to academic commentators such as reddy, aujla and gill, hbv falls within the broad spectrum of dv. Breaking the cycle of violent conflict with johan galtung.
Cultural violence by johan galtung 1990 towards life. Cultural violence are those aspects of culture, the symbolic sphere of our existence exemplified by religion and ideology, language and art, empirical science and formal science logic, mathematics that can be used to justify, legitimize direct or structural violence. The author rejects the narrow view of violence as the. Mark vorobej a broad definition of peace that incorporates. The pioneering professor of peace and conflict research, johan galtung, was the first to coin the phrase structural violence.
Finally, in the conclusion the threads of these approaches are drawn together with a focus on peace action. The theory is based on the principle that peace must be defined by widely accepted. Understanding the role of culture in domestic violence 37 eastern, and southeast asian countries, as well as immigrants from mexico and central america. In his paper violence, peace, and peace research, galtung made his highly significant and now widely. Introduction and theories introduction case vignette monica is a 43yearold woman who works as an executive in a large pharmaceutical company.
Galtung, violence, and gender 333 333 galtung, violence, and gender. Johan galtung has 80 books on goodreads with 2007 ratings. Galtungs articulation of direct, structural, and cultural violence offers a unified framework within which all violence can be seen. The concept of cultural violence urges us to consider the larger narratives of violence that undergird and influence our educational systems and which our writing pedagogies reproduce. Structural violence as a human rights violation kathleen ho abstract. The researchers in the current study adopted a plan of action using a systematic method to establish and implement specific strategies and policies to prevent workplace violence against health care professionals in jordan. Violence, peace, and peace research by johan galtung international peace research institute, oslo 1. With the french thinker michel foucaults conception of power and domination, a reinterpretation of galtungs famous concepts of structural violence and positive and negative peace is called for. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Definition of domestic violence differs between cultures. Violence triangle johan galtungs conceptualisation.
Structural violence is a term commonly ascribed to johan galtung, which he introduced in the article violence, peace, and peace research 1969. Cultural violence galtung galtung institut academia. Violence is any avoidable insult to basic human needs, and, more generally, to sentient life of any kind, defined as that which is capable of suffering pain an enjoy wellbeing. Request pdf on jan 1, 20, johan galtung and others published johan galtung find, read and cite all the. Cultural violence johan galtung college of social sciences, university of hawaii, manoa this article introduces a concept of cultural violence.
Jan 20, 2011 a noted pioneer in the field of peace studies, johan galtung makes the case for incorporating human rights as key to successful peace building around the world. This is the first ever anthology of key articles by johan galtung, widely. The term structural violence was coined by johan galtung to articulate the hidden violence in our midst, built into the structure of society itself and therefore more difficult to pinpoint and eradicate. The us is on one hand loved for its republican qualities, and on the other loathed by its enemies abroad for its perceived military aggressions. Structural violence, also referred to as social injustice, is defined as injustice and. This region is also one of the most densely populated % of the citys population live in 4. Cultural violence in the classroom cambridge scholars. May 28, 2014 violence triangle johan galtungs conceptualisation. Cultural violence makes direct and structural violence look or feel right, or at least not wrong, according to galtung. Cultural issues related to domestic violence cultural attitudes and barriers issues or influences counseling tips domestic violence occurs in all cultures and races, including all american ethnic minorities. The parties may be inside a person, a state or nation, a region or civilization, pulling in different directions. Here i will summarize the three main types of violence. Interventions often target intimate partner and youth violence. Galtung notes behind all this violence triangle is cultural violence 1999.
Conflict transformation by peaceful means the transcend method 2 as violence may enter, basic concepts in violence theory like direct, structural and cultural violence are explored. The relations between direct, structural and cultural violence are explored, using a violence triangle and a violence strata image, with various types of casual flows. Positive and negative peace both result in physical or psychological harm personaldirect there is a clear actor that. Therefore, so as to investigate the linkages between the three different types of violence, i shall be adopting a more bilateral approach by exploring connections between cultural violence to structural violence and direct violence to structural violence. But the violence triangle has builtin vicious cycles. Johan galtungs concept of cultural violence uk essays. In 1969, johan galtung published a paper called violence, peace, and peace research,8 with the goal of establishing a definition of violence to set an agenda for peace research. Violence, peace, and peace research johan galtung, 1969. Contributions and limits of johan galtungs work for the analysis of violent conflicts in this. Utilising data extracted from interviews conducted with 30 key agents, this. Conflict transformation by peaceful means the transcend. Sierra leone gained independence from the british empire in 1961.
In johan galtungs 1969 paper, violence, peace and peace research, he presents his theory of the conflict triangle, a framework used in the study of peace and conflict, with the purpose of defining the three key elements of violence that form this triangle. Cultural violence johan galtung, 1990 journal of peace research. Johan galtung a mini theory of peace the basic point is that peace is a relation, between two or more parties. In handbook of peace and conflict studies, edited by charles webel and johan galtung, 143159.
Building a global culture of peace includes myriad components and a variety of platforms with which to engage and transform violence. Some aim to reduce dating violence and sexual abuse among teenagers and young adults. The seminal article cultural violence galtung, 1990 illuminated cultural variables responsible for legitimizing. Often elites must use direct violence to curb the unrest produced by structural violence. Structural violence mark vorobej over the past forty years, johan galtung has extensively employed a broad definition of peace that incorporates the notion of structural violence. Galtungs cultural violence encompasses arendts suprahuman ideologies and can both be analysed in relation to the nationstate. May 22, 2017 johan galtungs recent account of 60 memorable and useful lessons learned from that period of his work can be read in launching peace studies the first prio yearspublished in 2010 by transcend university press popular. Download citation the concepts of peace and cultural violence. Feb 21, 2017 this article introduces a concept of cultural violence, and can be seen as a followup of the authors introduction of the concept of structural violence over 20 years ago galtung. According to giorgio gallo and arturo marzano the clear separation is only useful in order to theoretically understand and explain a conflict. Any concept of peace includes the absence of direct violence between states, engaged in by military and others in. Tackling and preventing such issue of workplace violence necessitates reinforcing and reviving existing policies. This involves an exploration of cultural violence focusing on the deeper aspects of cultures. When foucault forces us to consider power as productive and when the aim of social justice is problematized, how do we then address the issue of structural violence as an object of transformation.
The public health approach to violence is based on the rigorous requirements of the scientific method. Galtungs structural violence and the sierra leone civil. All of galtungs ancestors for several generations were medical doctors and nurses. Cultural violence is a symbolic violence that is expressed in countless media religion, ideology, language, art, science, media, education, etc and serves to legitimize direct and structural violence and to inhibit or suppress the response of the victims. Examples of cultural violence are indicated, using a division of culture into religion and ideology, art and language, and empirical and formal science.
Understanding violence triangle and structural violence. Johan galtung, one of the founders of modern peace studies, provides a wideranging panorama of the ideas, theories and assumptions on which the study of peace is based. This is the first ever anthology of key articles by johan galtung, widely regarded as the founder of the academic discipline of peace studies. Galtungs theory needs to incorporate notions of gender as a social construct embodying relations. Jstors terms and conditions of use provides, in part, that unless you have obtained prior permission, you may not download an entire issue of. In johan galtungs 1969 paper, violence, peace and peace research, he presents his theory. Other articles where cultural violence is discussed. Developing a policy for workplace violence against nurses and health care professionals in jordan. Johan galtung has shown that there are several different ways of classifying the phenomenon of violence. Direct, structural, and cultural forms of violence and peace often referred to as the father of peace studies, norwegian theorist johan galtung has developed a three pronged typology of violence that represents how a confluence of malleable factors merge in particular culturalhistorical moments to shape the conditions for the promotion of violence and, by inference. Galtung, johan cultural violence language, violence. The rise and rise of repressive techniques and technologies pdf. Stalenoi the peoples war and johan galtungs conflict models 34 and in a conflict more than one type of asymmetry may exist, each with variable degrees of intensity.
Several issues complicate efforts to end domestic violence. Perspectives and hope from galtung and buber article in educational philosophy and theory november 2015 with 109 reads how we measure reads. Access to society journal content varies across our titles. It was here that she met her boyfriend, richard, who. This discussion examines the work of galtung on the idea of cultural violence and how this has influenced our understanding of conflicts. However, the recent emphasis on the concept of positive peacereferring to a condition of society in which. Galtung s structural violence and the sierra leone civil. Introduction in the present paper we shall be using the word peace very many times.
Structural and cultural violence in religion and peacebuilding. Confortini my paper argues for an incorporation of feminist theories into peace theories, by analyzing what is missing by not confronting feminist contributions to a theory on violence. Cultural violence is defined here as any aspect of a culture that can be used to legitimize violence in its direct or structural form. Cultural violence makes direct and structural violence look, even feel, right. Galtungs expanded perspective in this article is helpful in considering the larger contexts of structural violence. This content was written by a student and assessed as part of a university degree. Galtungs theory of structural violence sociology essay. Cultural violence johan galtung journal of peace research. Cultural violence johan galtung, 1990 sage journals. Discuss johan galtungs concept of cultural violence and consider critically its.
Direct, structural, and cultural forms of violence and peace. This briefing describes how cultural and social norms can support violence, gives examples of interventions that interventions. Direct violence reinforces structural and cultural violence. Terrorists, serial killers, domestic murderers their ghoulish deeds fill our news and popular entertainment, interspersed with wars, riots, and brutal repressions.
But the invisible effects may be even more vicious. Johan galtung pioneer of peace research johan galtung. Of those, less than 10% sought help from the police. Johan galtung available for download and read online in other formats. Direct violence is supported by the culturally violent notion of just war theory, which argues that under certain conditions, it is acceptable to kill others e. For galtung, simplistic stereotypes that identify entire cultures as violent are not very helpful. It causes much suffering and can lead to conflict, war, and genocide. According to galtungs violence triangle 1969, cultural and structural violence cause direct violence. On the other hand, feminism can contribute to and enrich galtungs theory of violence in four possible ways. Few words are so often used and abused perhaps, it seems, because peace serves as a means of obtainingverbal consensusit is hard to.
Galtung, johan cultural violence language, violence, and. Peace is not a property of one party alone, but a property of the relation between parties. Transcend media service galtungs structural violence and. Violence against women 1 in 3 women have experienced physicalsexual violence at some point in their lives. First theorized by johan galtung a father of peace studies, cultural violence makes other forms of violence. The study of cultural violence highlights the ways the act of direct violence and the fact of structural violence are legitimized and thus made acceptable in society. Oct 12, 2012 galtung s structural violence and the sierra leone civil war c. Ahmad rayan 1, ali qurneh 2, rana elayyan 2, omar baker 3.
611 974 566 1496 32 396 171 338 1012 712 953 1527 149 1461 1145 1318 910 280 1086 1479 799 1037 170 542 1119 244 1012 1339 186 1349 589 1109 175 141 879